hp-64-vs-hp-64xl-page-yield

InkLedger is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This helps us keep the lights on and the ink flowing, allowing us to continue our mission of finding the best deals and alternatives to expensive OEM cartridges.

HP 64 vs HP 64XL: Real-World Page Yield Comparison

The HP 64 and HP 64XL are common ink cartridges used in several popular HP Envy and HP OfficeJet printers. While they look identical, the key difference lies in the amount of ink they hold, directly impacting page yield and overall cost-effectiveness. Choosing between the standard HP 64 and the high-yield HP 64XL can significantly affect your printing budget. Let’s dive into a real-world comparison to determine which cartridge offers the best value.

Understanding Page Yield: OEM Claims vs. Reality

HP, like other printer manufacturers, provides estimated page yields for their cartridges. These estimates are based on the ISO/IEC 24711 standard, which involves printing a standardized set of pages with 5% coverage. However, the problem is that your printing habits likely diverge wildly from that standard. If you print photos, documents with heavy graphics, or even just use a larger font size, you’ll get significantly fewer pages.

Therefore, it’s crucial to move beyond the manufacturer’s claims and consider real-world usage. We’ll examine typical printing scenarios and user experiences to provide a more accurate comparison of the HP 64 and HP 64XL.

Comparing Ink Volume and Initial Cost

The most apparent difference between the HP 64 and HP 64XL is the ink volume. While HP doesn’t explicitly state the exact ink volume in milliliters (ml), the XL version contains significantly more ink. This translates to a higher initial cost for the HP 64XL but potentially a lower cost per page in the long run.

Here’s a general comparison based on average retail prices (prices may vary):

• HP 64 Black: Typically costs between $20-$30.
• HP 64XL Black: Typically costs between $35-$50.

The price difference can be significant, but it’s essential to remember that you’re paying for more ink. The crucial question is whether the increased page yield justifies the higher upfront cost.

Calculating Cost Per Page: A More Accurate Metric

To determine the true cost-effectiveness, we need to calculate the cost per page (CPP). This metric tells us how much it costs to print a single page using each cartridge. Here’s how to calculate CPP:

1. Estimate Real-World Page Yield: Based on user reports and our own observations, the HP 64 black cartridge typically yields around 120-150 pages, while the HP 64XL black cartridge yields around 350-450 pages. These figures are far from the ISO standard, reflecting real-world documents.

2. Divide Cartridge Cost by Page Yield:

   • HP 64 Black: If the cartridge costs $25 and yields 135 pages, the CPP is $25 / 135 = $0.185 per page.
   • HP 64XL Black: If the cartridge costs $45 and yields 400 pages, the CPP is $45 / 400 = $0.113 per page.

As you can see, even with a higher initial cost, the HP 64XL offers a significantly lower cost per page. This difference adds up over time, especially for users who print frequently.

Beyond OEM: Exploring Compatible and Refill Options

While the HP 64XL offers a better CPP than the standard HP 64, both options can still be relatively expensive compared to alternatives. Compatible cartridges and ink refill kits offer potential cost savings, but they also come with their own considerations.

Compatible Cartridges: A Budget-Friendly Alternative

Compatible cartridges are manufactured by third-party companies and are designed to work with your HP printer. They are typically much cheaper than OEM cartridges, but the quality and reliability can vary. We’ve found some reliable brands, but be sure to read reviews and choose reputable sellers.

Potential Savings: Compatible HP 64XL cartridges can often be found for around $20-$30, potentially halving your ink costs.

Considerations:

• Print Quality: May not be as consistent as OEM cartridges.
• Reliability: Some compatibles may experience issues with printer recognition or leakage.
• Warranty: While using compatible cartridges should not void your printer warranty (thanks to the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act), HP may try to claim that the compatible cartridge caused damage.

Ink Refill Kits: The Most Economical (But Messy) Choice

For the budget-conscious user, refilling your own ink cartridges can be the most economical option. Ink refill kits typically include ink, syringes, and instructions for refilling empty cartridges. This method requires some patience and can be messy, but the savings can be substantial. We have a guide on [/pillars/mvp-pillar-3-storing-unused-cartridges-the-vacuum-sealing-trick/] that can help extend the life of cartridges you plan to refill.

Potential Savings: Refilling a cartridge can cost as little as $2-$5 per refill.

Considerations:

• Messiness: Refilling ink can be a messy process, requiring careful handling.
• Skill Required: Requires some technical skill and attention to detail.
• Print Quality: Print quality may degrade over time as the cartridge’s internal components wear out.
• Clogging: Improper refilling can lead to clogged printheads. See our guide on [/pillars/mvp-pillar-2-clogged-printhead-when-to-clean-vs-when-to-replace/] for more information on this issue.
• Ink Selection: Choosing the right ink is crucial for optimal print quality and printer longevity. Avoid generic inks of questionable quality.

Making the Right Choice for Your Needs

The best choice between HP 64, HP 64XL, compatible cartridges, and refill kits depends on your printing habits, budget, and tolerance for risk.

• High-Volume Printing: If you print frequently, the HP 64XL is generally the most cost-effective option due to its lower cost per page.
• Budget-Conscious Printing: Compatible cartridges offer a balance between cost savings and convenience. Research reputable brands and read reviews before purchasing.
• DIY Enthusiasts: Ink refill kits provide the greatest savings but require more effort and technical skill.
• Low-Volume Printing: If you print infrequently, the standard HP 64 may be sufficient, as the initial cost is lower. However, consider the expiration date of the ink; cartridges can dry out if left unused for extended periods.

Ultimately, understanding your printing needs and comparing the cost per page of different options will help you make an informed decision. And don’t forget to consider alternative printing solutions, like laser printers or tank printers, if your printing volume is high enough to justify the investment. Epson’s EcoTank line, for example, uses bottles of ink like [/products/b012iwr5x2-epson-664-ecotank-ink-ultra-high-capacity-bottle-yellow-t664/], which drastically reduces the cost per page.