brother-lc401-vs-lc401xl-cost

InkLedger is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. We maintain editorial independence; our reviews and recommendations are based on thorough research and real-world cost analysis, not brand influence. Our goal is to provide genuinely useful information to help you save money on printer ink.

Brother LC401 vs LC401XL: Cost and Page Yield Comparison

Choosing the right ink cartridge for your Brother printer can be confusing, especially when faced with options like the standard LC401 and the high-yield LC401XL. Both cartridges work in the same printers, but their cost and page yield differ significantly. Understanding these differences is crucial to making an informed decision that saves you money in the long run. Let’s dive into a detailed comparison.

What Printers Use the LC401 and LC401XL?

Before we get into costs, let’s clarify which printers use these cartridges. The Brother LC401 and LC401XL series are compatible with a range of Brother inkjet printers, typically those in the Brother MFC-J series. Some common compatible models include:

• Brother MFC-J1010DW
• Brother MFC-J1012DW
• Brother MFC-J1075DW
• And other printers that specifically list LC401 or LC401XL compatibility.

It’s always a good idea to double-check your printer’s manual or Brother’s website to confirm compatibility before purchasing any ink cartridges.

Page Yield: How Many Pages Can You Actually Print?

Page yield is the estimated number of pages you can print with a single cartridge. This is typically measured under controlled laboratory conditions, following the ISO/IEC 24711 standard. However, real-world printing can vary significantly based on factors like the type of documents you print, the amount of ink coverage, and your printer settings.

• Brother LC401 (Standard Yield): The standard LC401 cartridges typically yield around 200 pages for black and 200 pages for each color (cyan, magenta, yellow).
• Brother LC401XL (High Yield): The high-yield LC401XL cartridges offer a significantly higher page yield, typically around 500 pages for black and 400 pages for each color.

Important Note: These are estimates. If you print a lot of photos or documents with high ink coverage, you’ll likely get fewer pages. Similarly, if you print mainly text documents in draft mode, you might exceed these numbers.

Beyond the Official Numbers: Real-World Printing Scenarios

The ISO standard uses a 5% coverage per page, which is a small amount of ink. If you routinely print documents with graphics, photos, or bold text, your actual page yield will be lower. It’s also worth noting that infrequent printing can lead to ink drying out in the cartridge, further reducing the number of usable pages. See our guide to [/pillars/mvp-pillar-3-storing-unused-cartridges-the-vacuum-sealing-trick/] for tips on extending cartridge life.

Cost Comparison: Is the XL Really Worth It?

To determine the most economical choice, we need to compare the cost per page (CPP) for both cartridge types. This calculation takes into account the price of the cartridge and its estimated page yield.

Let’s assume the following average prices (these can fluctuate, so always check current prices):

• LC401 Black: $20
• LC401XL Black: $35
• LC401 Color (each): $25
• LC401XL Color (each): $40

Now, let’s calculate the cost per page:

• LC401 Black: $20 / 200 pages = $0.10 per page
• LC401XL Black: $35 / 500 pages = $0.07 per page
• LC401 Color: $25 / 200 pages = $0.125 per page
• LC401XL Color: $40 / 400 pages = $0.10 per page

As you can see, the LC401XL cartridges offer a lower cost per page for both black and color printing. This means that while the initial investment is higher, you’ll save money in the long run, especially if you print frequently.

Calculating Your Annual Ink Costs

To estimate your annual ink costs, consider how many pages you print each month. For example, if you print 100 pages of black and 50 pages of color documents per month, you can calculate your annual usage:

• Black: 100 pages/month * 12 months = 1200 pages/year
• Color: 50 pages/month * 12 months = 600 pages/year

Now, let’s calculate the number of cartridges needed per year:

• LC401 Black: 1200 pages / 200 pages/cartridge = 6 cartridges
• LC401XL Black: 1200 pages / 500 pages/cartridge = 2.4 cartridges (round up to 3)
• LC401 Color: 600 pages / 200 pages/cartridge = 3 cartridges per color (9 total)
• LC401XL Color: 600 pages / 400 pages/cartridge = 1.5 cartridges per color (round up to 2 per color, 6 total)

Finally, let’s calculate the annual cost:

• LC401 (Standard Yield): (6 * $20) + (9 * $25) = $120 + $225 = $345
• LC401XL (High Yield): (3 * $35) + (6 * $40) = $105 + $240 = $345

In this specific scenario, the annual cost is the same. However, the convenience of replacing cartridges less often with the XL version is a factor to consider. Plus, remember that ink prices fluctuate, so the XL version could potentially be cheaper overall.

Considering Combo Packs and Multipacks

Brother and third-party retailers often offer combo packs or multipacks that include multiple cartridges. These packs can sometimes offer significant savings compared to buying individual cartridges. Be sure to compare the cost per page of these packs to the individual cartridge prices to determine if they’re a better deal.

Third-Party Alternatives and Refilling Options

While OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) cartridges like the Brother LC401 and LC401XL are reliable, they can be expensive. Exploring third-party alternatives and refilling options can help you save even more money.

Compatible Cartridges

Compatible cartridges are manufactured by third-party companies and are designed to work with your Brother printer. They are typically sold at a lower price than OEM cartridges. However, quality can vary, so it’s essential to choose a reputable brand.

Pros:

• Lower cost
• Often offer XL versions

Cons:

• Quality can vary
• May not be recognized by your printer (rare, but possible)

Refilling Cartridges

Refilling your existing cartridges is another way to save money. You can purchase ink refill kits that come with ink and instructions on how to refill your cartridges. This option requires a bit more effort, but it can significantly reduce your printing costs. We have an article on [/products/b00mfg54b6-inkjet-refill-kit-pro-hp-canon/] that could be a good starting point.

Pros:

• Lowest cost per page
• Environmentally friendly

Cons:

• Can be messy
• Requires some technical skill
• Potential for print quality issues if not done correctly

When to Consider a Different Printing Solution Altogether

If you find yourself constantly replacing ink cartridges, it might be time to consider alternative printing solutions. Ink tank printers, like the Epson EcoTank or Canon MegaTank, use refillable ink tanks instead of cartridges. While the initial investment is higher, the cost per page is significantly lower, making them a great option for high-volume printing. Consider reading our article on EcoTank vs. MegaTank printers for a more in-depth look.

Conclusion: Which Cartridge Should You Choose?

In the battle of Brother LC401 vs LC401XL, the LC401XL generally offers a better value due to its lower cost per page. If you print frequently, the XL cartridges will save you money in the long run and reduce the hassle of frequent cartridge replacements. However, if you print very infrequently, the standard LC401 might be a better option to avoid ink drying out.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual printing needs and budget. By understanding the page yield, cost per page, and available alternatives, you can make an informed decision that saves you money and ensures you always have the ink you need. Always check current prices and consider combo packs or multipacks to maximize your savings.