How to choose printers

Printer ink has long been a source of frustration, but the truth is, the printer you choose dictates much of that cost. As a former analyst who spent a decade dissecting the pricing strategies of the printing industry, I’ve seen firsthand how manufacturers engineer their devices to lock you into their ecosystem. This guide isn’t about marketing fluff; it’s about equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed decision that saves you money in the long run.

InkLedger is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through our links.

Beyond the Sticker Price: Understanding True Cost of Ownership

The initial purchase price of a printer is often a smokescreen. Manufacturers frequently sell printers at or below cost, knowing they’ll recoup their profits (and then some) through consumable sales—ink cartridges, toner, and even specialized paper. This strategy, known as the “razor and blade” model, is pervasive in the industry. Your goal, as a savvy consumer, is to minimize the cost of the “blades.”

Ink Cost Per Page: The Only Metric That Matters

Forget about “page yield” numbers advertised on cartridge boxes. While they offer a theoretical maximum, they’re often based on ISO standards that don’t reflect real-world usage. A more accurate measure is the cost per page (CPP), which we meticulously calculate here at InkLedger.

Our methodology is straightforward: every cartridge we test is purchased at retail across three different sellers; we never accept manufacturer samples from OEM or third-party brands. Each cartridge prints a 200-page real-document workload (mixed text, photo, color) before we calculate cost per page. Retailer pricing is re-checked every Monday for at least 90 days post-publish; stale links are removed and the article is dated ‘last priced’.

When comparing printers, don’t just look at the price of a single cartridge. Look at the capacity of the cartridges and then divide the price by the estimated page yield (as reported by reliable third-party tests like ours, not just the manufacturer). Even better, look at printers designed for high-volume printing, which often feature larger ink tanks.

The Hidden Costs: Features and Functionality

While not directly related to ink, certain printer features can indirectly impact your overall cost and satisfaction.

• Wireless Connectivity: Essential for most modern homes and small offices. Look for Wi-Fi Direct or AirPrint/Google Cloud Print compatibility for seamless mobile printing.
• Automatic Document Feeder (ADF): If you scan or copy multi-page documents frequently, an ADF is a time-saver. Without it, you’re placing individual pages on the scanner bed, which quickly becomes tedious.
• Duplex Printing (Automatic Two-Sided): This saves paper and can significantly reduce your environmental footprint. Many budget printers only offer manual duplexing, which requires you to re-insert pages.
• Print Speed (PPM - Pages Per Minute): For occasional use, this isn’t critical. For a busy home or small office, slow print speeds can be a bottleneck.
• Scanner Resolution (DPI - Dots Per Inch): If you plan to digitize photos or detailed documents, higher DPI is beneficial. For general document scanning, 300-600 DPI is usually sufficient.

Inkjet vs. Laser: The Fundamental Divide

This is the most critical decision point. The “best” technology depends entirely on your primary use case.

Inkjet Printers: The Color and Photo Specialists

Inkjets spray microscopic droplets of liquid ink onto paper. They excel at producing vibrant colors and high-quality photographs, making them the go-to choice for families, creative professionals, and anyone who prints a lot of images.

Pros:

• Excellent color and photo quality.
• Lower initial purchase price (often).
• Can print on a wider variety of media (photo paper, glossy paper, cardstock).
• Compact size.

Cons:

• Ink can be expensive, especially for traditional cartridge-based models.
• Ink can dry out if not used regularly, leading to clogged print heads.
• Slower print speeds for text documents compared to lasers.
• Not ideal for very high-volume text printing.

Key Consideration: Ink Tank Systems (EcoTank, MegaTank, Smart Tank) This is where the inkjet game has fundamentally changed. Instead of small, expensive cartridges, these printers feature large, refillable ink tanks. While the initial printer cost is higher, the cost per page plummets. This is often the best choice for families or small businesses with moderate to high color printing needs.

For example, the Epson EcoTank ET-2800 offers an incredibly low cost per page for color and black-and-white documents, making it a favorite for parents dealing with school projects. Similarly, the Canon PIXMA G3270 MegaTank provides a similar value proposition with excellent print quality.

Laser Printers: The Text and Volume Workhorses

Laser printers use toner (a fine powder) and a heated fuser to bond the toner to the paper. They are incredibly fast, produce crisp text, and are designed for high-volume monochrome printing.

Pros:

• Extremely low cost per page for black-and-white text.
• Fast print speeds, especially for text.
• Toner doesn’t dry out like ink, making them ideal for intermittent use.
• High page yields from toner cartridges.
• Excellent for crisp, professional-looking text documents.

Cons:

• Higher initial purchase price, especially for color laser printers.
• Color laser printers are significantly more expensive to run than their monochrome counterparts.
• Not as good for photo quality as inkjets (toner doesn’t blend as smoothly).
• Larger footprint than most inkjets.
• Limited media compatibility (not ideal for photo paper).

Key Consideration: Monochrome vs. Color Laser If you only print black-and-white text documents (e.g., invoices, reports, school essays), a monochrome laser printer is almost always the most economical choice. Color laser printers have come down in price, but their toner cartridges are still expensive, and they consume four cartridges (black, cyan, magenta, yellow) compared to a monochrome’s single black cartridge.

A reliable and cost-effective option for a small office or home user needing primarily black and white prints is the Brother HL-L2370DW. It offers fast printing and relatively inexpensive toner options, especially if you consider [INTERNAL:third-party-toner-options].

Your Printing Profile: Matching the Printer to Your Needs

To make the right choice, you need to honestly assess your printing habits.

The Occasional Printer (1-10 pages/week)

You print boarding passes, a recipe here and there, or a single school permission slip.

• Recommendation: A basic inkjet multifunction printer (print, scan, copy) with traditional cartridges, but only if you’re prepared for the relatively high cost of those cartridges and potential print head issues from infrequent use. Alternatively, an entry-level monochrome laser printer if you never need color.
• Why: Inkjets are cheap upfront. Lasers won’t have ink drying out.
• Avoid: High-capacity ink tank systems – the higher initial cost isn’t justified for such low volume.

The Family Printer (10-50 pages/week)

School reports, homework, occasional photos, concert tickets, recipes, household documents. You need a balance of text and color.

• Recommendation: An inkjet multifunction printer with an ink tank system (Epson EcoTank, Canon MegaTank, HP Smart Tank).
• Why: Low cost per page for both color and black, handles diverse printing needs, and the larger ink supply means less frequent refilling. This is where the initial investment pays off quickly.
• Consider: Automatic duplexing and an ADF for scanning multi-page homework.

The Small Office/Home Office (SOHO) Printer (50-200+ pages/week)

Invoices, contracts, reports, shipping labels, occasional marketing materials, presentations. Reliability and low cost per page are paramount.

• Recommendation:
  • Mostly Text: A monochrome laser multifunction printer. Fast, reliable, and incredibly cheap to run for black and white.
  • Mix of Text and Color: A color ink tank system inkjet, or a color laser printer if print speed is critical and the budget allows for higher toner costs.
• Why: Laser for high-volume text; ink tank for high-volume, cost-effective color. Speed and reliability are key for productivity.
• Consider: Network connectivity, robust paper handling, and advanced scanning features. [INTERNAL:best-printers-for-small-business]

The Photo Enthusiast (Frequent photo printing)

You print family photos, art prints, or professional proofs.

• Recommendation: A dedicated photo inkjet printer, often with more than the standard four ink colors (e.g., six or eight-ink systems for wider color gamut and smoother transitions).
• Why: Superior photo quality, wider color accuracy, and ability to print on specialized photo papers.
• Consider: Specific pigment-based inks for archival quality, and borderless printing capabilities.

What to Avoid: Traps for the Unwary

• “Free” or Heavily Discounted Printers: These are almost always loss leaders designed to hook you into expensive ink. If the printer seems too cheap to be true, it probably is.
• Proprietary Ink Subscriptions (unless you’ve done the math): Services like HP Instant Ink can offer convenience, but carefully calculate if your actual usage aligns with their tiers. Many users find they overpay or undershoot, leading to wasted money or insufficient ink. [INTERNAL:is-instant-ink-worth-it]
• Printers with Tri-Color Cartridges: These cartridges combine cyan, magenta, and yellow into one unit. If one color runs out, you have to replace the entire cartridge, even if the other two colors are full. Always opt for printers with individual color cartridges.
• Printers without Third-Party Ink Options: Some manufacturers use DRM (Digital Rights Management) or proprietary chip technology to prevent third-party cartridges from working. This severely limits your options for [INTERNAL:affordable-ink-alternatives] and drives up your costs. We prioritize printers where third-party options are readily available and reliable.

Bottom Line

Choosing a printer isn’t about finding the cheapest device on the shelf; it’s about understanding the long-term cost of ownership. As an analyst who’s seen the inner workings of this industry, I can tell you that manufacturers profit from your ignorance of ink costs. By focusing on cost per page, assessing your actual printing needs, and leaning towards ink tank systems for color or monochrome lasers for text, you can break free from the cycle of overpaying for printer ink and make a truly informed decision. Your wallet will thank you.