brother-ink-cartridge-savings

InkLedger is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Our recommendations are based on years of tracking ink pricing and testing alternatives, not on manufacturer incentives.

Brother Ink Cartridge Savings: Comparing Standard, High-Yield, and Third-Party Options

Brother printers are known for their reliability and affordability, but the cost of ink can quickly add up. Understanding the different cartridge options available – standard yield, high-yield, and third-party compatibles – is crucial for minimizing your long-term printing expenses. This article breaks down the cost savings associated with each option, helping you determine which is the best fit for your printing needs.

Understanding Brother Ink Cartridge Options

Brother offers a range of ink cartridges designed to fit different printing volumes and budgets. The primary distinctions lie in the yield (number of pages printed) and the price per cartridge.

• Standard Yield Cartridges: These are the most common and least expensive upfront. They are suitable for light to moderate printing needs, such as occasional documents and photos.
• High-Yield Cartridges: Also known as “XL” cartridges, these contain more ink and offer a significantly higher page yield compared to standard cartridges. While they have a higher initial cost, they often provide a lower cost per page, making them ideal for frequent printing.
• Third-Party Compatible Cartridges: These cartridges are manufactured by companies other than Brother and are designed to work with Brother printers. They are typically the least expensive option upfront, but quality and reliability can vary.

Calculating Cost Per Page: The Key to Savings

The most effective way to compare ink cartridge options is by calculating the cost per page (CPP). This metric allows you to determine the actual cost of each printed page, taking into account both the cartridge price and the expected page yield.

How to Calculate Cost Per Page

The formula for calculating cost per page is simple:

Cost Per Page = Cartridge Price / Page Yield

To illustrate, let’s consider a hypothetical example using Brother LC3011 standard yield cartridges and LC3013 high-yield cartridges. Note: specific pricing and yield can vary depending on the retailer and printer model.

Example:

• Brother LC3011 (Standard Yield Black):
  • Price: $20
  • Page Yield: 200 pages
  • Cost Per Page: $20 / 200 = $0.10 (10 cents per page)
• Brother LC3013 (High-Yield Black):
  • Price: $35
  • Page Yield: 400 pages
  • Cost Per Page: $35 / 400 = $0.0875 (8.75 cents per page)

In this example, the high-yield cartridge offers a cost savings of 1.25 cents per page. While this may seem insignificant, it can add up to substantial savings over time, especially for users who print frequently.

Real-World Example: LC3017 vs LC3019

Brother’s LC3017 and LC3019 series provide a good case study for high-yield vs. standard. The LC3019 is the “XL” version. While the initial cost is higher, the per-page cost is often lower. As we covered in our explainer, Brother LC3017 vs LC3019 — the XL trap, explained, it’s crucial to check current pricing and page yields for your specific printer model to make an informed decision.

Evaluating Third-Party Compatible Cartridges

Third-party compatible cartridges can offer significant cost savings compared to OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) cartridges. However, it’s essential to approach these options with caution and conduct thorough research.

The Pros and Cons of Compatible Cartridges

Pros:

• Lower Price: Compatible cartridges are typically much cheaper than Brother-branded cartridges.
• Potential for Higher Yield: Some compatible cartridges offer a higher page yield than standard or even high-yield OEM cartridges.

Cons:

• Variable Quality: The quality of compatible cartridges can vary significantly between brands. Some may produce faded prints, leak ink, or cause printer errors.
• Warranty Concerns: While using compatible cartridges generally does not void your printer warranty (as we explain in detail in our article, Will Using Compatible Ink Cartridges Void Your Printer Warranty?), it’s important to be aware of the manufacturer’s warranty terms. A printer manufacturer cannot void your warranty simply for using third-party ink, but they are not responsible for damage caused by a faulty third-party cartridge.
• Inaccurate Ink Level Readings: Some compatible cartridges may not accurately report ink levels to the printer, leading to unexpected interruptions during printing.

Tips for Choosing Reliable Compatible Cartridges

• Read Reviews: Look for reviews from other users who have used the same compatible cartridge with your printer model. Pay attention to comments about print quality, reliability, and customer service.
• Check for Certifications: Some manufacturers of compatible cartridges obtain certifications, such as ISO 9001, which indicate adherence to quality management standards.
• Buy from Reputable Retailers: Purchase compatible cartridges from reputable retailers that offer a satisfaction guarantee or return policy.
• Consider Refill Kits: If you are comfortable with a bit of DIY, consider an ink refill kit. As we cover in How to Properly Refill Ink Cartridges: A Step-by-Step Guide, this can lead to significant savings.
• Start Small: Before committing to a large purchase of compatible cartridges, buy a single cartridge to test its performance in your printer.

Long-Term Cost Analysis and Decision-Making

Choosing the right Brother ink cartridge option requires careful consideration of your printing habits and budget. A long-term cost analysis can help you make an informed decision that saves you money in the long run.

Estimating Your Annual Printing Volume

The first step is to estimate your annual printing volume. Consider the types of documents you print (text, graphics, photos), the frequency of printing, and the number of pages you typically print per month.

Comparing Costs Over Time

Once you have an estimate of your annual printing volume, you can compare the costs of standard yield, high-yield, and compatible cartridges over a longer period, such as one year or three years.

Example:

Let’s assume you print 1000 pages per year and are considering the following options:

• Brother LC3011 (Standard Yield Black): $0.10 per page
• Brother LC3013 (High-Yield Black): $0.0875 per page
• Compatible Cartridge: $0.06 per page

Annual Costs:

• Standard Yield: 1000 pages x $0.10/page = $100
• High-Yield: 1000 pages x $0.0875/page = $87.50
• Compatible: 1000 pages x $0.06/page = $60

Over three years, the cost differences become even more significant:

• Standard Yield: $100/year x 3 years = $300
• High-Yield: $87.50/year x 3 years = $262.50
• Compatible: $60/year x 3 years = $180

This analysis clearly demonstrates the potential for long-term savings with high-yield or compatible cartridges.

Beyond Cartridges: Alternative Printing Solutions

It’s also worth considering alternative printing solutions that can reduce your reliance on ink cartridges altogether:

• EcoTank Printers: These printers use refillable ink tanks instead of cartridges. While the initial cost is higher, the cost per page is significantly lower. We’ve done extensive testing on Is an Epson EcoTank Printer Worth It? Cost Analysis vs. Cartridges & Lasers.
• Laser Printers: Laser printers use toner instead of ink. Toner cartridges typically have a higher page yield than ink cartridges, and the cost per page can be lower, especially for black-and-white printing. Also, see our guide to Best Third-Party Toner Cartridges for Laser Printers: 50% Savings Without Sacrificing Quality.
• Going Paperless: Whenever possible, opt for digital alternatives to printing. This can save you money on both ink and paper. See our articles on Going Paperless: Digital Alternatives to Printing That Actually Save Money and Beyond Printing: Practical Alternatives to Going Paperless.

By carefully evaluating your printing needs, comparing cartridge options, and considering alternative solutions, you can significantly reduce your Brother ink cartridge expenses and save money in the long run.